Monday, March 3, 2008

Have you eaten?

“Hi Lena! Have you eaten?” the guy who watches the garage asks me as I walk by everyday. Why is this guy so hung up on whether or not I have eaten all the time? Why is everyone in this country so hung up on whether or not I have eaten?! I eat! Trust me!

If a friend in the States asked me that typically means “I’m hungry, wanna grab a bite?” So, at first I thought I was just being asked out to lunch a lot. But that wasn’t right, people are really friendly here but strangers weren’t asking me to lunch!

Then, I thought they were just perplexed as to whether or not I ate. It was more like “Are you adjusted to green chilies yet?”

As it turns out “Have you eaten” is just another way of saying “How are you?” I hear this is common in countries that have had to deal with huge famines.

Instead of saying:
1: How are you?
2: Well, I’m not so great…
1: Why aren’t you so great? What’s wrong?
2: Well, I haven’t eaten today, you know, famine and all. *

They cut right to the chase! If you have eaten, you must be doing a-okay and no need to ask. Once I figured that out, I started to understand why I was getting weird looks…

A: Hello, have you eaten?
Me: umm, yeah, I had rice and vegetables with a nice Oyster sauce about an hour ago. I bought the vegetables from the market. It was delicious.
A: oh.

B: Hey Lena. Have you eaten?
Me: No, I’m going right now to grab some coffee.
B: coffee? That’s something you have in the afternoon!
Me: oh.
B: you are only drinking coffee?

C: Have you eaten?
Me: um, no. Do you…want to get lunch?
C: what?
Me: never mind. Have you eaten?
C: Yes. Have you eaten?
Me: Yes.
C: smiles comfortably.


*this conversation is a product of Lena’s mind and likely did not actually occur.

3 comments:

Robin said...

Ha ha...that is too funny. "so have you eaten?"

A.B. said...

Ha! I've read about this in linguistics books!!! PS Gatsby is super cute, and Karina is wearing one of the hoodies I gave her when I left OR! I'm so happy about that!

mwibbe01 said...

heeehee.

-melissa